According to FemaleFirst, the 39-year-old star, who just reunited with singer John Mayer, is thinking of giving romance a second chance with Donovan.
A source close to Aniston revealed, "Jennifer cannot believe it. A few months ago she was single and heartbroken, and now she has got two men professing their love for her."
"Tate has been in touch with Jennifer on and off over the years. But this time it was different. He called her again and again and hinted they should start dating. Jennifer thought it was a joke at first, but she is immensely flattered and is considering her options," added the source.
Aniston and Donovan broke up in 1995, after dating for three years.